Testimonials
"Kelly Macdonald is a true master of her craft. Not only does she provide feedback where writing can improve in a way that feels encouraging, but she also provides in depth analysis of the writing as a whole. I would highly recommend her to any and all writers of varying levels of experience." ~ Janeth Corral - Short story submission beta read - Febraury 2026
"Kelly of KMacdonald Editing provided beta reading feedback on my debut fantasy novel, and the experience exceeded my expectations. Her feedback was specific, balanced, and deeply engaged. She understood my characters, caught my foreshadowing, and gave me precise, actionable notes rather than vague impressions. Most impressively, she completed a 126,000 word manuscript in four days without any sacrifice in quality. If you're looking for a beta reader who will treat your work with genuine care and seriousness, I wholeheartedly recommend Kelly." ~ Makailah Avalos - Manuscript beta read - April 2026